The following guest blog post comes from our newest board member, Dr.Tim Porter-O'Grady. Given the historical vote in Congress last night, coupled with the rising call for evidence-based medicine, Tim's perspective from the trenches is very timely. You can also read Tim's recent article in Nurse Leader magazine on the case for clinical nurse leaders in the 21st century.
One of the big challenges with leaders and clinicians these days is the overwhelming amount of data that must be collected, codified, generated, and analyzed. A big temptation in this necessary effort is to watch data management convert from means to ends. As I travel around the country working with a wide variety of health care agencies, I see clinicians overwhelmed with trying to balance the collection and management of data with the demands of patient care. While data is important, leaders must remember that clinical and management data should be directed to supporting, improving, and advancing patient care not simply a nonaligned means of the measure of process.
When the demand for measurement becomes overwhelming, it moves from tool to goal. When data becomes a goal it moves from facilitator of practice to an impediment to work. In fact, it begins to undo its very purpose and itself become a "workaround" and just another barrier to effective patient care. For many clinical leaders the demand for information and the urge to collect and provide it becomes more important than the real sustainable achievement of value or outcome. One wonders how many clinicians are now working to instrumentation measures, making those measures their performance goals, losing focus on their patient in the process. While the collection of this data is certainly essential to the methods and techniques essential to measuring the presence of effective process, they are indicators, not results.
It must be remembered, in the midst of all this data collection, that clinicians are providing a service deeply embedded in the context for caring to persons experiencing one of the most significantly vulnerable points in their life's journey. These patients are expecting that the focus, attention, and center of clinical activity are directed to helping them cope, respond, and accommodate their healing journey. The real value-driven measures are those that well articulate a goodness-of-fit between the needs for caring and the resources necessary to assure that it occurs efficiently and effectively.
The best measure of the utility of data is that which assures that mission, purpose, resources and care interface in a mosaic where the patient expresses exuberance with their experience, the clinician expresses satisfaction with her or his impact and management recognizes value in the efficiencies leading to sustainable outcomes. The achievement of these ends is reflected in the essential dance between the stakeholders and the organization and the music is the information that demonstrates their convergence.
So, finally, it is important for each stakeholder to both recognize and enumerate value in the collection and analysis of data related to the dynamic of caring for patients. Equally important is to acknowledge that data is reflective of value and action, it is not, however, itself value and action. Measurement of the meaningful delivery of service is not the service itself but, rather, is indication of the effectiveness and efficacy of the service. There are three things that must continuously be kept in mind when interfacing data management with clinical care:
In the final analysis, sound relationships are the best indicators of both efficacy and meaning. The relationships between health organizations and their clinicians, between clinicians and those they serve, and between health organizations and their communities are the clearest indicators of effectiveness. Data and measurement devices are the lenses through which the value and impact of these relationships can be assessed for both their quality and effectiveness. If all stakeholders in this dynamic keep focused on the ends of advancing the health of those we serve, the data means we use will provide the evidence we need for the validation we seek in fulfilling the central purpose of the caring we provide. Quite frankly, that is why we are here.
© 2022 Workforce Institute All Rights Reserved • Designed and Developed by Morether Creative Agency, Temple, TX